I’ll admit I’m a little bit upset about the election. No, unlike many of the Bishops, I’m not in mourning about Obama’s reelection. In case you missed last week’s post, I’m perfectly fine with that outcome.
No. I’m talking about the sentiments I saw on election day and the days following. One facebook post summed up the election as between a “ warmongering, religious homophobe” and an “economically ignorant demagogue. ” Or as I mentioned in last week’s post, Stanley Hauerwas’ called it a “Roman Circus.” I won’t even get into this.
It’s become quite popular nowadays to be a political cynic, whether among the religious who feel their faith not being represented as they understand it, the well-educated who feel the political sound bites and slogans we often hear miss the true complexity of the issues we face, or your average citizen complaining of political hypocrisy.
There’s certainly a lot of hypocrisy in our political system. Take Mike Bowers. Bowers was born in 1942 in Commerce—a small town in rural Georgia, that in 1940 had a population of not quite 3,300. The son of a truck driver, he went on to graduate from West Point in 1963, and served in the air force until 1970, when he attended the University of Georgia Law School. He was elected attorney general of Georgia from 1981-1997, and made a record for himself fighting government corruption.
Sounds like a pretty cool guy, right?
Unfortunately for his legacy in the history books, Bowers is best known as the defendant in two cases: Bowers v. Hardwick, and Shahar v. Bowers. In the first case in 1986, Bowers convinced the Supreme Court to uphold a Georgia anti-sodomy law, and in the second, Bowers convinced the Eleventh Circuit uphold his 1991 rescinding of an employment offer to Robin Shahar, upon his finding that she had recently married another women in a Reformation Jewish marriage ceremony. At first glance, one could argue that Bowers was just doing his job of enforcing statutes the elected legislature had passed. In Shahar, he argued that he was justified firing her because “inaction on my part would constitute tacit approval of this purported marriage and jeopardize the proper functioning of this office,” that she would be unable to enforce the state’s anti-sodomy laws, and he had doubts about the quality of Shahar’s judgment “in general” as seen in her choice to get seek employment in the state attorney's office while getting married to a women, despite the controversy in Georgia following Bowers. However, the lawyers arguing for Shahar knew that Bowers had been having a longtime affair with a member of his staff—as against Georgia’s anti-adultery law (O.C.G.A. §16-6-19). The man who was arguing that a lesbian couldn’t enforce Georgia’s morality statutes on account of her violation of them was himself actively violating them!
So, yes, frustration with our politics is quite valid. At the same time, we, the voters, often make matters worse. We caricaturize the candidates, dehumanize them to be an issue, rather than people in and of themselves. But Romney is not some impersonal robot incapable of feelings and out to oppress 47% of America. Obama is not some demon antichrist with plans to invade the US with UN troops. They have their own thoughts and feelings, hopes and dreams, (and, yes, even tears). They are public figures, and so subject their political views to public criticism, as Obama has pointed out. However, in holding ourselves proudly aloof and criticizing a system while not working to change it, we make ourselves no better than those we criticize.
Christianity is a religion of hope, not cynicism. We believe in the best, not worst, of what it is to be human. The beauty of democracy is that if you don’t like something, you can work to change it. If no one represents you to your satisfaction, you can run for office yourself. I admit, you’ll probably have an uphill battle—what with our two party system and all. However, there is no beatitude, “blessed are the cynics.” Jesus didn’t forget to finish the “love your neighbor as yourself” with “…except for that political bozo on the TV.”
Ultimately, there is a lesson in the frustration of politics. A friend of mine posted on facebook perhaps my favorite election-day post: "No matter who wins the election today, they won't be perfect. And that's okay; the position of savior has already been taken."
We are not perfect, and our politics is not perfect. Heaven knows, if it were then we’d have some serious question to ask regarding the Catholic teachings of human fallenness and original sin. However, the Catholic response is not cynicism—not holding ourselves aloof in some fortress of self-righteousness. When St. Paul writes to the Romans, “There is no one righteous, not even one,” he doesn’t counsel cynicism. He counsels hope, and faith in God.
As Chris Tomlin explains his song, “God of This City,” the Christian band Bluetree was in Pattaya, Thailand—a city known for its sex industry and child prostitution. A bar (more descriptively, a brothel) called “The Climax Club” was desperately looking for a band, to play and asked Bluetree, so long as they would bring their sizable crowd of missionaries with them. In the middle of the set, surrounded by the poles for dancers and looking out over the missionaries--heavily involved with their Cokes, Aaron Boyd, the lead singer for Bluetree, was struck with the notion that God was still present. God was the “God of this city, the King of these peoples.” As he described it, in the middle of the set, he started chanting—started singing—those words. This “minor, downbeat loop,” eventually opened up into the lyrics “the greater things have yet to come, and greater things are still to be done yet in this city.” After all, even a city “vitiated by sin” is a city over which God still is God—still the “light in this darkness…the hope to the hopeless…the peace to the restless.”
Remember Bowers, the Attorney General of Georgia who fired a women for a sexual crime while he was committing one of his own? In May 1997, he resigned his position as attorney general to run for governor. Just a week after a final decision by the Eleventh Circuit in his favor in Shahar, Bowers admitted to his affair. He lost in the 1998 primary. Bowers was overturned in 2003 by Lawrence v. Texas, which stated “Bowers was not correct when it was decided, [and] is not correct today.”
Our political world is far from perfect, but it has a tendency to work itself out in the long run. But those imperfections are important; they remind us we shouldn’t seek our savior in a politician. At the end of the day, we are responsible for our own holiness—there is no miracle politician or law that we must have or cannot do with out. It reminds us that, ultimately, the greatest things are yet to come.
We already have our savior; let’s focus on getting to know Him better, and not on expecting politics to create a new one.
A practicing Catholic (with apologies to James Carroll) in Law School asking questions and trying to figure out a better answer to Life, the Universe, and Everything than 42.
Showing posts with label Hope. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hope. Show all posts
Sunday, November 11, 2012
Sunday, August 5, 2012
The Correct Resolution
This past Wednesday, I was able to see the
Venezuelan-American pianist Gabriela Montero perform at the Chicago Symphony
Orchestra’s (CSO) summer home at Ravinia, just north of Chicago. After her performance of the Grieg Piano
Concerto—an old favorite of mine—she took a tune unfamiliar to both me and her
that a random audience member sung for her and improvised on it. (For the musically-inclined: she added
counterpoint to a random melody on the
spot.)
Improvisation, or making up music as you go along, is
normally strictly the realm of jazz pianists, but Montero has made a name for
herself by creating improvisations based on well-known (or less well known)
tunes suggested to her by the audience.
She does it with all sorts of music:
a Classical/Baroque Happy Birthday, Rachmaninoff’s 3rd piano concerto à la Bach or à la jazz, a Romanticized national anthem of Scotland, and a latinized Harry Potter.
Certainly, if you transcribed Montero’s improv, it probably
wouldn’t satisfy music theory professors who critique composers who spent years
on their compositions. But my jazz piano
teacher in High School always said there is no wrong note in improvisation. Whatever
note you play is the right one, no matter how weird it sounds to the ear. The
trick, though, is how you “resolve” the note you just played. If your note was dissonant, building tension or
perhaps downright discomfort in the listener, do you relieve that tension with
a harmonic note, or purposely build it up further for a later release? The true art of improvising is making that
choice deliberately and correction. So “There
is no wrong note in improv—just incorrect resolutions.”
This makes me think of how God works in our lives. In his allegory, “The Music of the Ainur” from
The Silmarillion, J.R.R. Tolkien describes
the act of God’s creation as that of a composer directing His musicians (angels)
in improvised variations on His theme. Tolkien
writes of God as the master improviser and composer, while the Devil attempts
to insert His own themes and creations over and above God’s. Eventually, there are two clearly different
musics being played at once. God’s “was deep and wide and beautiful, but slow
and blended with an immeasurable sorrow, from which its beauty chiefly came,”
while the Devil’s was “loud, and vain, and endlessly repeated; and it had
little harmony, but rather a clamorous unison of many trumpets braying upon a
few notes.” While the Devil’s music
might try to drown out God’s by sheer force of violence, somehow “its most
triumphant notes were taken by [God’s] and woven into [God’s music’s] own
solemn pattern.”
I’m always skeptical of the “it’s all in God’s plan”
reassurances when things are going rough.
It’s hard to look at the Aurora shootings and say “Yup, God’s plan at
work. Isn’t it beautiful?” It seems loud. And vain.
And endlessly repeated.
So instead of being endlessly distracted by the discord, I
started looking for God’s resolutions, for no matter what notes the Devil may
insert, the Master Improviser could certainly resolve them in a way to make
even the most ugly act a part of a beautiful composition. Then, I read this article a friend had sent me
a few days after the shootings, and I realized that here was just one small example of God doing just that,
and I saw in a moment of resolution a piece of God’s grace.
God gave us free will, and as a result, a lot of things against
His law happen. And it is so easy to
allow the Devil’s dissonance to crowd out God’s melody of grace and hope. Those of us forced to live with the discord
can only strive to make sure that we don’t cause it and have the faith to look
for those moments of resolution, for in those moments, we find not only grace,
but hope. And not only does hope save us,
but with faith, perhaps God will begin to call on us to be a vehicle of hope to
another person. And that is the greatest
gift of all.
Sunday, May 27, 2012
Only Hope
There’s a song that’s inside of my soul

This week, I have been discovering the depths of my pack-rattedness while
I do a post-graduation clean out my room.
My collection of classical recital programs and ballroom dance club
membership cards shall make some historian 500 years from now extremely happy (students
shall think that my life is typical! It shall be God’s practical joke on
turn of the millennium American pop “culture.) While cleaning the shrine to dead—erm—immortal arts that is my room, I
found one of my favorite songs I’ve accompanied: “Only Hope,” made famous by Mandy Moore in the movie A Walk to
Remember.
I’m awake in the infinite cold,
But
You sing to me over and over again.
Summers after each year of Duke have been marked by the same thing:
loneliness. Sure, I’m remarkably
close with my High School friends—but they’re not always around. And if I’m totally honest, even when
surrounded by the love of the friendships I’ve made at Duke, or when I see my Chicago
friends who are like a second family to me, I can still feel alone. As thankless and undeserving as it makes
me feel, there are times that even my closest friends somehow just aren’t
enough.
So
I lay my head back down,And I lift my hands and pray
“Lord, ‘It is not good that man be alone.’ My God, please let me have a boyfriend—or even just a date.”
To be only Yours, I pray
To
be only Yours.
“Don’t You see it, my Lord?
If I could just have a guy to call my own, it would fix everything—loneliness,
self-esteem. All I need is a boyfriend; then, I’d be happy.”
I know now You’re my only hope.
Shortly after that prayer, I would go to some Catholic event and see Fr.
Mike in his habit, and I couldn’t fight the shame that would come. After all, a boyfriend doesn’t fix
loneliness. My campus minister
once told me how people, even after they are happily married, still feel
loneliness.
Sing
to me the song of the stars,
Of
Your galaxy dancing and laughing and laughing again.
| And He will raise you up on eagles' wings. |
When it feels like my dreams are so far,
Sing
to me of the plans that You have for me over again.
When
we turn towards ourselves, how can we see anything but the beauty and love that
it took to create us? Isn’t all we
need to complete us God alone? Or are we so blinded by our own griefs and
desires that we do not see the hand that holds us? Or have we learned to hate ourselves so much that when we
are held in the palm of His hands, we see sinners in the hands of an angry God,
moving swiftly towards the fires of Hell? If God is merely a promise of Hell, no wonder we seek refuge
in other people. We may be fallen
and broken, but being fallen and broken doesn’t stop His love for us—why should
it stop our own? Even when we
strike out alone from the path he created for us, He finds His lost sheep, and
guides us another way that will lead to the gates of heaven.
And
I lay my head back down,
And
I lift my hands and pray
“How, oh Lord, how can we be lonely when You wrote Yourself into every
one of Your creations? How can we
feel unloved when You have given us everything.”
To
be only Yours, I pray
To
be only Yours.
“Lord,
whenever I blind myself to the truth and start to feel lonely, reveal Your face
in everything around me—Your hand guiding every move I make.”
I
know now You’re my only hope.
Loneliness
requires both an acute awareness of the self and a feeling of separation of
that self from its surroundings.
But that “I” only exists through the incessant tending of God, and He
knows me more perfectly than I know myself. Perhaps loneliness comes from forgetting Plato’s immortal
instruction: “Know thyself.” After all, God is in me, so if I know myself well
enough, I must know Him.
I’m
giving You all of me.
I
want Your symphony.
Singing
in all that I am.
God
is never alone—He is the perfect union of Father and Son from which proceeds
the Holy Spirit—if we have one, we have all three. But more than that, Christ is the head of an entire Body. That the Eucharist is the Body of
Christ has the dual meaning of it being the flesh of Christ and the communion of saints. Being in Communion means we are never
alone: each Mass is a play-date
with Christ. Each Mass is a play-date with every Catholic who has ever lived. Perhaps I didn’t see you today, but if
you went to Mass and received the Eucharist, I did something better—I saw you
in the Eucharist.
At
the top of my lungs,
I’m
giving it back
And,
as Gaudium et Spes says, we are only complete “through
a sincere gift of self” (25). No
wonder at Duke I felt least lonely, and most a member of the Body of Christ, when
giving back. It is lack of
service that makes me feel incomplete—not lack of a particular person.
And
I lay my head back down,
And I lift my hands and pray
“My God, thank you for the precious gift of your Body and the community
of the faithful. However far we
all may be, I am with people I never even new existed.
To be only Yours, I pray
to be only Yours.
to be only Yours.
“True loneliness, I know, would only be separation from You, for
I know now You're my only hope."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

